Questrade
Asset-segregation composite governed by the weaker axis — (segregation × ) = 7.3, (custody tier) = 8.0. Dimension score = 7.3.
Capped at 7.0/10 — no negative-balance protection (jurisdiction not mandating it).
No (jurisdiction not mandating it). Withdrawal Integrity is capped at 7.0/10 regardless of other withdrawal performance (it would otherwise be 9.2). Approximate composite impact: −2.8 points.
Questrade, Inc. scores 84/100 (Excellent) under TVSM-BR/1.0.1. Primary strength is Regulatory Standing: active CIRO investment dealer across all Canadian provinces with no conditions, CIPF CAD $1M per account category, and Lloyd's CAD $10M excess-of-CIPF coverage that applies to all clients -- not a premium-tier perk. Largest drag is Asset Segregation (D3): Questrade's margin-collateral disclosure does not contain the explicit >=103% daily set-aside language present in IBKR's margin agreement; methodology assigns rung 6 under the ambiguity principle. A second drag is Withdrawal Integrity (D5): the raw score of 9.2 is capped at 7.0 because Canada is a non-negative-balance-protection jurisdiction -- the same ceiling that holds IBKR's D5 at 7.0. No CIRO/IIROC enforcement in trailing 60 months; all historical actions resolved with no client-asset loss.
Canadian self-directed investors who want a CIRO-regulated broker with CIPF coverage and Lloyd's excess insurance; buy-and-hold equity and ETF portfolios in CAD and USD accounts; traders who value no inactivity fees and free EFT withdrawals.
You need contractual margin-collateral segregation guarantees beyond CIRO Rule 4300 omnibus segregation; or you require a broker domiciled in an NBP-mandating jurisdiction.
TraderVerdict brokerage scores assess custodial safety from a Canadian investor perspective. Scores do not constitute investment advice. Verify all details directly with the broker before opening an account.
Scores are on a 1–10 scale. = one step on the scoring ladder. Source links open primary evidence.